Control of Battlefields and Showdowns
Two areas that were unclear in the rules update were control of battlefields and when Showdowns open. How battlefield control is managed is contradictory in two places: in the control rules under rule 187.4.c., and in the cleanup rules under rule 323.6. To clarify this: rule 323.6. should read, “Players lose control of any controlled battlefields without their Units occupying them if the turn is in an open state and there is no Showdown or Combat ongoing there.” This was our intent, as seen in the patch notes, and the wording of rule 323.6 lagged behind it. 187.4.c. | If a player has no Units at a Battlefield and the turn is in an Open state, they lose Control of that Battlefield in the following cleanup, unless there is a Combat or Showdown ongoing there. 323.6. | (OLD) 4. If the turn is in an Open State, Battlefields with no Units occupying them and no Showdown or Combat ongoing become Uncontrolled. (NEW) 4. Players lose control of any controlled Battlefields without their Units occupying them if the turn is in an open state and there is no Showdown or Combat ongoing there. The second of these areas is how Showdowns are opened. Here, the cleanup rules are correct and take precedence over the other rules. Rule 316.5.b. should read, “A Showdown is marked as staged at a battlefield in the cleanup after the Contested status is applied to that battlefield.” Rule 344.2. should read, “If Control of a battlefield is Contested and there aren’t units controlled by different players there, a Showdown is opened during the Cleanup at the end of the action that caused the battlefield to become Contested.” For example, if a player moves a unit to a battlefield they don’t control, they will apply the Contested status to that battlefield immediately upon becoming located there, regardless of whether there are units controlled by another player there or not. The battlefield having the Contested status causes a Showdown to be staged there in the following cleanup per rule 323.8. The previous wording of 316.5.b. implied that a Showdown will only be staged at a battlefield if that battlefield is uncontrolled, but the change to how Showdowns become Combats means Showdowns need to be able to be staged when the battlefield is still controlled. 323.8. | 6. Mark a Showdown as Staged at each Battlefield that Contested was applied to. 316.5.b. | (OLD) A Showdown is marked as Staged at a Battlefield when the Contested status is applied to a Battlefield with no current controller. (NEW) A Showdown is marked as staged at a Battlefield in the cleanup after the Contested status is applied to that Battlefield. 344.2. | (OLD) If Control of a Battlefield is Contested and the Battlefield in question is uncontrolled when it becomes Contested, a Showdown is opened during the Cleanup at the end of the action that caused the Battlefield to become Contested. (NEW) If Control of a Battlefield is Contested and there aren’t units controlled by different players there, a Showdown is opened during the Cleanup at the end of the action that caused the Battlefield to become Contested.
Related: Rule 190.4.c, Rule 316.5.b, Rule 316.8.b, Rule 323.5, Rule 323.6, Rule 323.7, Rule 323.8, Rule 344.2